Dual-layer spectral detector CT for differentiating middle ear cholesteatoma and chronic suppurative otitis media
Author Block: S. Zhou1, L. Mei1, H. Liu1, X. M. Liu2, J. Li1; 1Changsha/CN, 2Guangzhou/CN
Purpose: To compare the diagnostic performance of dual-layer spectral detector CT (DLCT) and high-resolution CT (HRCT) in differentiating middle ear cholesteatoma and chronic suppurative otitis media.
Methods or Background: This prospective, institutional review board-approved study included sixty-six patients who were preliminary diagnosed as cholesteatoma or otitis media, and received DLCT scanning before surgery. Thirty-three patients were finally diagnosed cholesteatoma based on intraoperative or pathological findings. Two blinded readers (Reader 1: one radiologist; Reader 2: one otologist) provided diagnoses and diagnostic confidence scores using a five-point scale, based on HRCT images and DLCT multi-parameter images, including virtual mono-energetic image at 40keV (VMI 40keV) and effective atomic number (Zeff). Diagnostic accuracy of HRCT and DLCT maps were compared using McNemar’s test. Interobserver agreement was evaluated by Kappa statistic.
Results or Findings: HRCT and DLCT identified a total of 27/33 and 31/33 cholesteatomas by Reader 1, 19/33 and 30/33 cholesteatomas by Reader 2 respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, accuracy of HRCT and DECT by Reader 1 were 81.8, 75.8, 77.1, 68.2, 78.8% and 93.9, 69.7, 75.6, 92.0, 87.5%, by Reader 2 were 57.6, 90.9, 86.3, 68.2, 74.2% and 90.9, 75.8, 78.9, 89.3, 83.3%, respectively. Compared to HRCT, the diagnostic sensitivity of DLCT increased for both readers, with a statistically significantly improvement in Reader 2 (p<0.05). Diagnostic confidence scores of DLCT versus HRCT by Reader 1 and Reader 2 both improved significantly (4.85±0.36 vs 3.77±1.30, 4.44±0.73 vs 3.45±0.98, respectively, all p<0.05). Interobserver reproducibility was higher for diagnoses made with DLCT maps (k =0.717) than for that made with HRCT images (k = 0.495).
Conclusion: Spectral CT improved diagnostic performance and interobserver reproducibility of determination of cholesteatoma versus otitis media.
Limitations: None
Funding for this study: None
Has your study been approved by an ethics committee? Yes
Ethics committee - additional information: lRB of Xiangya Hospital