Detection of MRI edema patterns in patients with acute neck infections: a prospective blinded multidisciplinary and multicenter interobserver human performance evaluation
Author Block: J-P. T. Vierula, J. Velhonoja, A. Sirén, J. Nurminen, M. J. Nyman, K. Mattila, J. Hirvonen; Turku/FI
Purpose: In patients with acute neck infections, MRI shows reactive edema patterns that predict disease severity: retropharyngeal edema (RPE) and mediastinal edema (ME). How well radiologists and clinicians with diverse backgrounds and neck MRI experience can detect these edema patterns is unknown.
Methods or Background: This prospective, blinded, multidisciplinary, multicenter interobserver study evaluated human performance in detecting RPE and ME from axial in-phase and water T2-weighted Dixon images. Readers (N=28, including radiologists, neuroradiologists, radiology residents, head and neck surgeons) from all five university hospitals in Finland were briefly trained and assessed the presence of RPE and ME (yes/no) and rated their confidence (1-5) blinded to clinical data. Emergency MRI images were obtained from 60 patients with acute neck infections. Ten patients appeared twice to assess intraobserver variability. Sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and interobserver agreement were assessed.
Results or Findings: Overall sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were 0.89, 0.81, and 0.85 for RPE and 0.85, 0.81, and 0.82 for ME. ME accuracy correlated with confidence (p=0.002), whereas RPE accuracy did not (p=0.580). Radiologists achieved higher RPE sensitivity (p=0.01), RPE accuracy (p=0.04), ME sensitivity (p=0.01), and ME accuracy (p=0.02) than clinicians, whereas other group comparisons were not significant. High confidence was found for RPE (4.3) and ME (4.1). Overall, interobserver kappa was 0.61 (substantial) for RPE and 0.52 (moderate) for ME, with radiologists showing higher agreement than clinicians. Median intraobserver accuracy was 90% for both RPE and ME.
Conclusion: We show high diagnostic accuracy and substantial interobserver agreement for detecting clinically relevant reactive edema patterns on MRI in patients with acute neck infections. These results encourage using these biomarkers in clinical practice.
Limitations: Limited availability of emergency MRI.
Funding for this study: This study was financially supported by the Sigrid Jusélius Foundation. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Has your study been approved by an ethics committee? Not applicable
Ethics committee - additional information: A waiver for patient consent was not sought because it is not required by the national legislature for retrospective studies of existing data.