Synthesising and adapting multiple data sources to design environmentally sustainable and clinically effective imaging pathways for visible haematuria
Author Block: J. B. John1, K. O'Flynn2, S. Lambracos3, B. Abdelqader4, S. Nalagatla4, S. Khadouri5, T. W. R. Briggs3, W. K. Gray3, J. Mcgrath1; 1Exeter/UK, 2Salford/UK, 3London/UK, 4Glasgow/UK, 5Leeds/UK
Purpose: To design a risk-stratified imaging pathway that reduces greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions using diagnostic performance evidence for ultrasound and computerised tomography urogram (CTU) in detecting upper tract urothelial cancer (UTUC).
Methods or Background: An audit of 15 UK hospitals’ first-line imaging for visible haematuria (VH) and non-visible haematuria (NVH), and use of one-stop cystoscopy and imaging, was performed. Urology referral data from the IDENTIFY study (N = 10,896) were linked to national Hospital Episode Statistics data to estimate absolute numbers of patients receiving ultrasound or CTU first-line across England annually.
Results or Findings: Ultrasound was the first-line imaging choice for VH and NVH in 53% and 93% of hospitals respectively; other hospitals used CTU as first-line. One-stop assessment was performed in 44% of audited cases. An estimated 127,701 ultrasound and 77,880 CTU were performed across England annually, including an estimated 20% and 2% of additional CTU for patients with VH and NVH respectively receiving ultrasound first due to persistent VH.
Informed by these data, a risk-stratified imaging pathway for patients with haematuria was developed. The pathway comprised: one-stop clinic ultrasound first-line for all, additional CTU for high-risk cases (VH + age>65 + smoking history), patient-initiated follow up direct to CTU for persistent VH if not performed initially. We estimate that this pathway could results in 191,097 ultrasounds, 51,320 CTU and 73% of assessments completed with one-stop assessment, leading to an estimated 269 tonnes CO2e reduction in net greenhouse gas emissions across England for one year. Around 0.1% of patients would have UTUC missed with first-line ultrasound on this pathway.
Conclusion: Adoption of this evidence-based pathway will reduce GHG emissions whilst delivering greater risk-stratified imaging use, improving equity of healthcare access and reducing unwarranted use of CTU.
Limitations: N/A
Funding for this study: Not applicable
Has your study been approved by an ethics committee? Not applicable
Ethics committee - additional information: Not applicable