A decade of varicocele embolizations: Success and recurrence
Author Block: M. Ni Mhiochain De Grae1, M. Alkhattab1, A. Alkadhimi2, M. Springael2, G. O' Sullivan1; 1Galway/IE, 2Dublin/IE
Purpose: Varicoceles are vascular lesions of the pampiniform plexus, affecting 10-20% of the population and found in 40% of men with primary infertility and 80% with secondary infertility. (1-4) Pain occurs in 2-10% of cases. (1,5) Treatment options include conservative management, percutaneous embolization, or surgery. (6) Percutaneous embolization, introduced in the late 1970s, has a technical failure rate of around 13% and recurrence rates ranging from 0.6% to 45%. (7,8)
This study evaluates success and recurrence rates of percutaneous varicocele embolizations at Galway University Hospital and Galway Clinic between 2009-2022, with a minimum follow-up of 18 months.
Methods or Background: Data collected included patient age, procedure date, access site, side of occurrence, previous interventions, treatment method, need for re-intervention, and recurrence rates. Technical success was defined as successful access to the gonadal vein and insertion of coil/sclerosant. Clinical success was assessed through follow-up consultations and ultrasound when available.
Results or Findings: The technical success rate was 94.7%, with 98.1% of successful embolizations achieving clinical success. Of 225 patients, 3.12% had prior failed surgeries, all treated successfully with IR, and 0.89% required surgical intervention. Telephone follow-ups (42.7% response rate) revealed a recurrence rate of 10.7% with an average follow-up of 8.03 years. The complication rate was 1.78%. Fertility outcomes showed 51.35% of patients had successful pregnancies, while 6.9% experienced ongoing fertility issues.
Conclusion: Our study of 225 patients is the largest to date, showing higher success rates (technical 94.7%, clinical 98.1%) and a 10.7% recurrence rate with long-term follow-up.
Limitations: This is a single centre retrospective review. 42.7% response to telephone consultation follow up.
Funding for this study: No funding.
Has your study been approved by an ethics committee? Yes
Ethics committee - additional information: Local ethics approval in Galway University Hospital.